Paper Awards
Most Influential Paper Awards
The VL/HCC community began this tradition in 2008. Each year a voting group — the current Steering Committee, the current Program Committee, and the program chairs of the VL/HCC conferences of the years being considered — reviews the papers from the VL/HCCs held one decade ago (and, until 2017, two decades ago), to select the papers from those decades that have had the most influence on VL/HCC research or commerce.
All community members are invited to nominate papers from those years. Once a shortlist is produced, the voting group members who do not have conflicts with the nominees review and vote for the most influential paper from each decade.
2026
2025
2024
2023
2022
2021
2020
2019
2018
2017
2016
2015
-
Empirically Evaluating the Use of Animations to Teach Algorithms
1994 IEEE International Symposium on Visual Languages
-
Gender: An Important Factor in End-User Programming Environments?
2004 IEEE Symposium on Visual Languages and Human Centric Computing
2014
-
1994 IEEE International Symposium on Visual Languages
-
1995 IEEE International Symposium on Visual Languages
-
Estimating the Numbers of End Users and End User Programmers
2005 IEEE Symposium on Visual Languages and Human Centric Computing
2013
-
Agentsheets: applying grid-based spatial reasoning to human-computer interaction
1993 IEEE International Symposium on Visual Languages
-
Six Learning Barriers in End-User Programming Systems
2004 IEEE Symposium on Visual Languages and Human Centric Computing
2012
-
Understanding and characterizing software visualization systems
1992 IEEE Workshop on Visual Languages
-
The immune system as a reactive system: modeling T cell activation with statecharts
2001 IEEE International Conferences on Human-Centric Computing
-
Using HCI techniques to design a more usable programming system
2002 IEEE International Conferences on Human-Centric Computing
2011
-
A Declarative Approach to Event-Handling in Visual Programming Languages
1992 IEEE Workshop on Visual Languages
-
First Steps In Programming: A Rationale for Attention Investment Models
2002 IEEE International Symposium on Human-Centric Computing
2010
-
The specification of visual language syntax
1989 IEEE Workshop on Visual Languages
-
Extending UML for Modeling of Multimedia Applications
1999 IEEE International Symposium on Visual Languages
2009
-
Prograph: A Step towards Liberating Programming from Textual Conditioning
1989 IEEE Workshop on Visual Languages
-
1999 IEEE International Symposium on Visual Languages
2008
-
HI-VISUAL: A Language Supporting Visual Interaction in Programming
1984 Workshop on Visual Languages
-
Diagram Editing with Hypergraph Parser Support
1997 IEEE International Symposium on Visual Languages
Best Papers and Honorable Mentions
Best paper, short paper, student paper, and honorable mention awards from individual symposia. Each entry links to a source confirming the award. This list is incomplete; a missing year or category does not mean that no award was given.
- 2026
- 2025
- 2024
- 2023
- 2022
- 2021
- 2020
- 2019
- 2018
- 2017
- 2016
- 2015
- 2014
- 2013
- 2012
- 2011
- 2010
- 2009
- 2008
- 2007
- 2006
- 2005
- 2004
- 2003
- 2001
- 2000
- 1999
- 1998
- 1994
2026
-
Best Paper
Plottery: A Code-Integrated GUI for Matplotlib
VL/HCC 2026
Award source: Plottery: A Code-Integrated GUI for Matplotlib
-
Best Short Paper
Where AI Use Is Normalized, Author Seniority but Not AI Disclosure Biases Code Review
VL/HCC 2026
Award source: Where AI Use Is Normalized, Author Seniority but Not AI Disclosure Biases Code Review
-
Best Long Paper Runner-Up
Plans Work in Mysterious Ways: Evaluating a Plan Mode for Spreadsheet Agents
VL/HCC 2026
Award source: Plans Work in Mysterious Ways: Evaluating a Plan Mode for Spreadsheet Agents
2025
-
Best Paper
HiLDe: Intentional Code Generation via Human-in-the-Loop Decoding
VL/HCC 2025
Award source: HiLDe: Intentional Code Generation via Human-in-the-Loop Decoding
-
Best Short Paper
The Command Line GUIde: Graphical Interfaces from Man Pages via AI
VL/HCC 2025
Award source: The Command Line GUIde: Graphical Interfaces from Man Pages via AI
-
Honorable Mention
SPARK: Real-Time Monitoring of Multi-Faceted Programming Exercises
VL/HCC 2025
Award source: SPARK: Real-Time Monitoring of Multi-Faceted Programming Exercises
-
Honorable Mention, Short Paper
From Tool to Partner: Exploring the Roles of Embodiment on AI Agent in Pair Programming
VL/HCC 2025
2024
-
Best Research Paper
Jigsaw: A Tool for Decomposing and Planning Programming Problems
VL/HCC 2024
Award source: Jigsaw: A Tool for Decomposing and Planning Programming Problems
-
Best Research Paper
Let’s Fix this Together: Conversational Debugging with GitHub Copilot
VL/HCC 2024
Award source: Let’s Fix this Together: Conversational Debugging with GitHub Copilot
2023
-
Best Paper
Detangler: Helping Data Scientists Explore, Understand, and Debug Data Wrangling Pipelines
VL/HCC 2023
-
Honorable Mention
FxD: a functional debugger for dysfunctional spreadsheets
VL/HCC 2023
Award source: FxD: a functional debugger for dysfunctional spreadsheets
-
Best Short Paper
Coder and Coder Cards: A Novel Tangible Programming Approach for Young Programmers
VL/HCC 2023
Award source: Coder and Coder Cards: A Novel Tangible Programming Approach for Young Programmers
-
Honorable Mention, Short Paper
Exploring the Barriers and Factors that Influence Debugger Usage for Students
VL/HCC 2023
Award source: Exploring the Barriers and Factors that Influence Debugger Usage for Students
2022
2021
-
Best Research Paper
Edit-Run Behavior in Programming and Debugging
VL/HCC 2021
Award source: Edit-Run Behavior in Programming and Debugging
-
Best Short Paper
Guided Optimization for Image Processing Pipelines
VL/HCC 2021
Award source: Guided Optimization for Image Processing Pipelines
-
Honorable Mention
Exploring Machine Teaching with Children
VL/HCC 2021
-
Honorable Mention, Short Paper
VL/HCC 2021
2020
-
Best Research Paper
Exploring Programmers’ API Learning Processes: Collecting Web Resources as External Memory
VL/HCC 2020
-
Best Short Paper
EdCode: Towards Personalized Support at Scale for Remote Assistance in CS Education
VL/HCC 2020
Award source: EdCode: Towards Personalized Support at Scale for Remote Assistance in CS Education
2019
-
Best Paper
Software Developers Learning Machine Learning: Motivations, Hurdles, and Desires
VL/HCC 2019
Award source: Software Developers Learning Machine Learning: Motivations, Hurdles, and Desires
-
Honorable Mention
Editable AI: Mixed Human-AI Authoring of Code Patterns
VL/HCC 2019
Award source: Editable AI: Mixed Human-AI Authoring of Code Patterns
-
Best Short Paper
Studying the Benefits and Challenges of Immersive Dataflow Programming
VL/HCC 2019
Award source: Studying the Benefits and Challenges of Immersive Dataflow Programming
-
Honorable Mention, Short Paper
Effects of Code Representation on Student Perceptions and Attitudes Toward Programming
VL/HCC 2019
Award source: Effects of Code Representation on Student Perceptions and Attitudes Toward Programming
2018
2017
2016
-
Best Paper
Yestercode: Improving Code-Change Support in Visual Dataflow Programming Environments
VL/HCC 2016
Award source: Yestercode: Improving Code-Change Support in Visual Dataflow Programming Environments
-
Honorable Mention
Visual Discovery and Model-Driven Explanation of Time Series Patterns
VL/HCC 2016
Award source: Visual Discovery and Model-Driven Explanation of Time Series Patterns
2015
-
Best Paper
An fMRI Analysis of the Efficacy of Euler Diagrams in Logical Reasoning
VL/HCC 2015
Award source: An fMRI Analysis of the Efficacy of Euler Diagrams in Logical Reasoning
-
Honorable Mention
Natural Language and Programming: Designing Effective Environments for Novices
VL/HCC 2015
Award source: Natural Language and Programming: Designing Effective Environments for Novices
-
Honorable Mention
Tutorons: Generating Context-Relevant, On-Demand Explanations and Demonstrations of Online Code
VL/HCC 2015
-
Best Short Paper
Extending Scratch: New Pathways into Programming
VL/HCC 2015
Award source: Extending Scratch: New Pathways into Programming
2014
-
Best Long Paper
How Developers Use Multi-Recommendation System in Local Code Search
VL/HCC 2014
Award source: How Developers Use Multi-Recommendation System in Local Code Search
-
Best Short Paper
Automatic Layout in the Face of Unattached Comments
VL/HCC 2014
Award source: Automatic Layout in the Face of Unattached Comments
2013
2012
-
Best Paper
VL/HCC 2012
-
Best Student Paper
Informing the Design of Situated Glyphs for a Care Facility
VL/HCC 2012
Award source: Informing the Design of Situated Glyphs for a Care Facility
2011
-
Best Paper
An Exploration of Design Opportunities for “Gardening” End-User Programmers’ Ideas
VL/HCC 2011
Award source: An Exploration of Design Opportunities for “Gardening” End-User Programmers’ Ideas
-
Best Short Paper
Aesthetic of Angular Resolution for Node-Link Diagrams: Validation and Algorithm
VL/HCC 2011
Award source: Aesthetic of Angular Resolution for Node-Link Diagrams: Validation and Algorithm
2010
2009
2008
-
Best Paper
Dimension Inference in Spreadsheets
VL/HCC 2008
2007
-
Best Paper
Design Planning in End-User Web Development
VL/HCC 2007
-
Best Short Paper
Antecedents to End Users’ Success in Learning to Program in an Introductory Programming Course
VL/HCC 2007
2006
-
Best Paper
VL/HCC 2006
2005
2004
2003
-
Best Paper
Development and Evaluation of a Model of Programming Errors
HCC 2003 · End-User and Domain-Specific Programming
Award source: Development and Evaluation of a Model of Programming Errors
-
Best Paper
A Reading Algorithm for Constraint Diagrams
HCC 2003 · Visual Languages and Formal Methods
2001
-
Best Paper
UML-based Behavior Specification of Interactive Multimedia Applications
HCC 2001 · Visual/Multimedia Approaches to Programming and Software Engineering
Award source: UML-based Behavior Specification of Interactive Multimedia Applications
-
Best Paper
The Immune System as a Reactive System: Modeling T Cell Activation with Statecharts
HCC 2001 · Visual Languages and Formal Methods
Award source: The Immune System as a Reactive System: Modeling T Cell Activation with Statecharts